The Pipeline That Vanished
In 2009 Richard Mattus had some twenty projects to destroy coal mine methane in discussion across nine countries. After Copenhagen, almost all of them disappeared. As COP31 meets, the engineer who built the world's first commercial plant explains what was lost, and why it is still the cheapest climate action on offer.
"All these just vanished."
Drawn on the map
At one large coal mine in Australia's Hunter Valley, the plans had gone further than talk. The board papers included maps of the site with the new units already drawn in, beside the ventilation shaft. The installation would have been four or five times the size of the first one Richard Mattus had built. By his estimate, it would have destroyed some 50,000 tonnes of methane a year from a single shaft.
It was never built. Nor were most of the other projects he was negotiating in 2009: in Australia and China, the United States and Mexico, Poland, Ukraine, Russia, Turkey and India.
The first one
Mattus joined MEGTEC, an emission control company, in 1995. In 2003 it brought him back, after a few years away, to negotiate with BHP Billiton for something no one had built: a commercial plant to destroy the methane in a coal mine's ventilation air. If he landed the contract, he would build a business around it. He landed it at Easter 2004.
The plant at BHP's West Cliff colliery in New South Wales, known as WestVAMP, was officially opened in September 2007. It generated about 5 megawatts of electricity from mine methane and cut about 250,000 tonnes of CO₂-equivalent a year. The local commissioning team had been "very suspicious of these boxes", he recalls. "They were impressed when they saw that they worked from the start." It ran for ten years, as planned, until the mining moved away from that shaft.
What the boxes do
Coal holds methane, formed with it over millions of years. Mining releases it, and because methane explodes at concentrations of 5 to 15% in air, mines blow enormous volumes of fresh air through their workings to keep it far below that level. What comes out of the ventilation shafts is breathable air carrying 0.1 to 1% methane: ventilation air methane, or VAM.
That is the opening. "In emission control, it's a general truth that if you can assemble an emission, then you can mitigate it." The machine for the job is a regenerative thermal oxidiser, or RTO: in essence a steel box holding beds of ceramic. The ceramic heats the incoming mine air until the methane oxidises; the heat released is caught again by cooler ceramic on the way out, so the process largely sustains itself. Industry has used the same technology since the 1970s to clean solvent fumes from factories. Some 40,000 units have been installed worldwide. "When the VAM application started, it was already a mature technology."
Copenhagen
What made the projects possible was money for the tonnes. Under the Kyoto Protocol, the Clean Development Mechanism and the carbon markets that grew alongside it gave a value to each tonne of emissions avoided. An investor could set that value against the cost of building and running a plant, and the sums worked.
The first Kyoto period ran from 2008 to 2012. In December 2009, the Copenhagen conference was meant to extend it. It did not. For investors in plants that take eighteen months to build, and need four or five years of reliable revenue to pay back, the horizon closed.
A few plants were still built over the following decade, in the United States and China. Australia stopped entirely. Mattus puts it simply: the application went into hibernation for ten years. The projects that vanished, he estimates roughly, would have cut 6 to 8 million tonnes of CO₂-equivalent a year.
When he tells politicians and journalists this, the reaction is always the same, he says: "What? Why?" His answer: industry invests when it can calculate a return. Take the value of the tonne away, and the investment goes with it. Who gained from that? He does not hesitate. "The fossil fuel industry."
An emergency brake
Mattus left MEGTEC in 2012 to work as an independent consultant, but he never let go of methane. He kept attending the UN Economic Commission for Europe's Group of Experts on Coal Mine Methane in Geneva, and kept in touch with the handful of companies that had learned to build these plants safely.
When the group's chair asked him to coordinate and lead the writing of UNECE's Best Practice Guidance on ventilation air methane mitigation, he saw a way to put that experience on record. What writing it taught him was that the technology is not in dispute. The obstacle is attention.
And some coal is not going away soon. Metallurgical coal, used to make steel, is about 15% of global coal production, and hydrogen cannot yet replace it at scale. These are often the gassiest mines. "Met coal will be there for several decades to come," he says. "So we need, as soon as possible, to cap those emissions."
The 0.2% question
In the last few years a new doubt has circulated: that the oxidisers do not work at the lowest concentrations, around 0.2% methane. Mattus finds the timing telling. Plants are built for richer air, 0.4 to 1%, because a plant costs much the same whatever the concentration while its value rises with the methane destroyed. Some plants have run at 0.2% when mines proved leaner than expected, and suppliers report stable operation as low as 0.17 or 0.18%. Asking for formal proof at the very bottom of the range is, in his view, "a way to delay implementation".
The proof now exists. Peak Carbon's plant in Wales, commissioned in spring 2026, has deliberately run on air diluted to 0.2% since June, sustaining itself without added fuel. Mining engineers and UN organisations have visited, and the independent verifier Bureau Veritas has audited it on site.
Seven dollars a tonne
The economics are the part that surprises people most. To make an investor act, Mattus says, a tonne of avoided emissions needs to be worth about $20, counted the standard way, over 100 years. But methane does most of its warming in the first two decades: over twenty years it traps 82 times as much heat as CO₂. Counted over the period that matters for slowing warming now, that same $20 buys nearly three times the climate effect — about $7 a tonne.
Set that against what governments say they will do. Capturing CO₂ from power plants and cement works, he says, costs around $200 a tonne; pulling it from the open air, around $1,000.
It is the same word Mats Andersson used in Part 1, from the other side of the table.
Trying again
What would bring the miners back? The same thing that brought them in the first place: a revenue for verified tonnes, or a penalty for emitting them, certain enough to invest against. Whether the mine builds the plant or a third party does is irrelevant, he says; what matters is that the methane is destroyed.
That is what Mattus is now working on, with Andersson and Clean Exit Advisory: a bond that would pay per verified tonne destroyed, built against a public taxonomy for coal mine methane that he has written. If it fails, he says, the cost is "wasted hours of work". If it works, and another fifty or so large plants are built in the next decade, the methane they destroy each year would, on his figures, outweigh all of Sweden's greenhouse gas emissions, even on the conventional 100-year count.
His message for COP31 is for Australia, whose Chris Bowen is the conference's President of Negotiations, and which is the world's biggest exporter of metallurgical coal. It should be at the forefront, he says, in securing finance to destroy ventilation air methane. "That would be very efficient, if you could take a leader seat in that."
Is he hopeful? When he explains all this, he says, people react with surprise: is it really that efficient, that cheap, that possible? Then why don't we do it?
This week he is in Taiyuan, China, at the UN-established International Centre of Excellence on Coal Mine Methane.
Next, Part 3: Mats Andersson and Richard Mattus answer the same five questions, side by side.
Richard Mattus
- Joined MEGTEC in 1995; led the negotiation of the world's first commercial ventilation air methane plant, WestVAMP, at BHP Billiton's West Cliff colliery (opened 2007).
- Lead author of UNECE's Best Practice Guidance on ventilation air methane mitigation 2025.
- Independent consultant since 2012; long-standing participant in UNECE's Group of Experts on Coal Mine Methane.
- Author of a public taxonomy for coal mine methane, on a coal mine methane bond concept.
Disclosure: Mats Andersson and Richard Mattus are developing a coal mine methane bond concept with Clean Exit Advisory Ltd. The taxonomy is held by Methane Brief CIC, publisher of The Methane Brief.
Sources
- Interview with Richard Mattus, November 2026, and written notes from him.
- BHP Billiton, "NSW Premier Morris Iemma opens world-first power generation project at BHP Billiton's West Cliff mine", 14 September 2007.
- UNECE, Best Practice Guidance on ventilation air methane mitigation.
- IPCC AR6, Working Group I (methane lifetime and warming potential).
- Naturvårdsverket, Sweden's greenhouse gas emissions 2024, June 2025.
Reporting, interviews and sourcing by Juneia Mallas & Kaj Embrén. Drafted with AI assistance; fact-checked and edited before publication.